Cord cutters, beware: AT&T's DirecTV buy affects you, too

Jun 25, 2014 1:29 AM

James Careless

Having cut the cable cord, you may glance at the current landscape of big cable providers snapping up slightly-less-big-though-still-large rivals and decide that these megadeals have nothing to do with you. After all, you're getting your entertainment from other sources--over-the-air antennas, online streaming services, and the like. What's it matter to you if AT&T buys up DirecTV or Comcast absorbs Time Warner Cable?

Quite a bit, as it turns out. Because it seems like one of the primary motivators for big cable providers getting even bigger is to make cord cutting an unattractive proposition.

That's not how the cable providers themselves might spin it. Indeed, in a regulatory filing earlier this month for its $48.5 billion DirecTV buy, AT&T contends that it will be better equipped to compete with Comcast once DirecTV is part of the fold, which means benefits to its subscribers. "Millions of consumers will benefit from new and improved bundles of broadband, video, and--due to AT&T's advanced network and nationwide customer base in mobile communications--wireless services," AT&T says in the executive summary of its regulatory filing. (You can read the full filing if you've got a lot of time on your hands and an insatiable thirst for regulatory paperwork.) AT&T repeated its promises Tuesday in a congressional hearing into the purchase, telling lawmakers that the deal will mean more competitive pricing among cable TV providers.

Programming behind a paywall

But read between the lines of AT&T's promises of "creating more value for programming partners and taking advantage of broader expertise in video, broadband, and wireless," and it's not hard to see a scenario where cord cutters get squeezed out.

Take sports. Buying DirecTV gives AT&T access to the satellite provider's popular NFL Sunday Ticket. Theoretically, AT&T could negotiate with the National Football League to extend this exclusive DirecTV service to the combined company's cable/fiber, wireless, telephone, and high-speed Internet subscribers--but to no one else. Those pie-in-the-sky dreams of someone like Google buying the rights to NFL games and making them available on the Internet? Forget about that happening. (At least cord cutters would still be able to stream broadcasts of NFL games from local network TV affiliates in some markets--assuming Aereo's ongoing legal battles are resolved in its favor.)

It's not just AT&T and DirecTV; a merged Comcast/TWC could control about 30 million cable subscribers, giving the merged company tremendous clout when it comes time to negotiate with TV content producers. And that's the big concern here: merged giants like AT&T/DirecTV and Comcast/TWC would be in an enhanced position to negotiate exclusives, preventing cord-cutters from seeing their favorite content online, especially live sports.

A bundle of trouble

And while programming may be at the front of the mind for cord cutters, there's also the matter of Internet access. A combined Comcast/Time Warner Cable, for example, is well positioned to offer even more preferential terms to people who bundle cable and Internet service into a single package, while penalizing cord cutters who just want broadband.

That poses a problem for anyone who doesn't subscribe to cable, says John Fetto, senior analyst of marketing & research at Experian Marketing Services. "The web is absolutely a serious venue for cord-cutters to access content," Fetto said. "Indeed, nearly a fifth of households that use Netflix or Hulu are cord-cutters."

And that's going to motivate mega-providers like the combined AT&T/DirecTV and an expanded Comcast to push multi-service bundling even further. The goal? Keep subscribers paying for content they don't want in order to get access to what they do.

"Although a la carte programming on the Web is possible, I don't think it is realistic from a business standpoint," says analyst Ian Olgeirson of media and communications research firm SNL Kagan. "It is not in the best interests of either the distribution network operators or the content owners to really break down their bundles and sell much smaller packages to consumers."

From the perspective of AT&T and Comcast, cord cutting is bad for business. And that's why their current business practices are aimed at frustrating it.

And they've got good reason for doing so. Fetto notes that only 6.5 percent of U.S. households are cord cutters, meaning they have high speed Internet, but no subscription to cable or satellite TV. Still, there's been a 44 percent relative increase in the share of households that are cord-cutters since 2010. "Interestingly, we're seeing that millennial households are almost twice as likely to be cord-cutters," Fetto notes, "which could potentially be a challenge to the current revenue models of cable and satellite companies if those households never become cable subscribers at all."

What's a cord cutter to do?

Despite the current wave of content distributor tactics, there are ways for cord-cutters to get much of the programming they desire without submitting to Big Cable/Fiber/Satellite. But the fact remains that the content distributors understand the ramifications of cord cutting to their bottom lines, and are thus motivated to do everything they can to make cord cutting as unattractive as possible.

To be fair, not all of the content distributors' tactics are negative. For instance, Dish Network is said to be putting together a basic over-the-top service that, for $20 to $30 a month, would give cord cutters access to some Disney-owned networks online, including ABC and ESPN.

Other price breaks might slow the cord-cutting trend. "Bringing the price of the combined cable and broadband packages down would likely help," Fetto says. "Another thing that may help would be for cable/satellite carriers to make it easier for customers to consume their content across multiple devices and from anywhere. The Internet makes consuming video on-the-go and across devices easier, but it can take a cord cutter considerable effort to find the video content they want to continue viewing online."

In the meantime, cord cutters would be well-advised to watch out for further mergers and to track the progress of the AT&T/DirecTV and Comcast/TWC deals. Just because you've walked away from a cable provider doesn't mean their influence over how you access programming has come to an end.


Pinterest peaks, Facebook falters in customer satisfaction survey of social sites

Billions of people use assorted social networking sites, but just how happy are they with the likes of Facebook, Twitter, and the rest? The American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI), which measures exactly that sort of thing, put out its latest report on consumer satisfaction with e-businesses--that's social media, search engines, and websites--and it's an interesting look at just which service's Like button is getting a workout.

Investigation of missing IRS email holds lessons for your business

Congress has been pursuing an investigation into alleged misconduct at the IRS, and as a part of that investigation it requested emails from former IRS director Lois Lerner for the timeframe in question. The response Congress got was those emails--along with any archive or backups of those emails--have been erased and are no longer available. There are legal and compliance requirements organizations must abide by when it comes to retention of information, and the IRS apparently dropped the ball.

Simpsons World to provide every Simpsons episode without costing you any d'oh!

An episode of South Park from a dozen years ago posits that no matter what plotline or joke or cultural reference you can conceive of, chances are that The Simpsons has already done it. Starting in October, you'll be able to verify that for yourself any time you want to.

Facebook's new Save feature lets you read clickbait (and other stuff) later

Watch out, Pocket. Move over, Readability. Facebook's getting into the read-it-later action with a new Save feature designed to--you guessed it--save content you find on the social network for later reading.

Why the Comcast call from hell is great news for customers

If you're currently a Comcast customer, pick up the phone, call the company, and politely explain that you're considering leaving. You could potentially save a bundle of money.

Expert Opinion


Our favorite iOS Apps, July edition

As we do every month, Macworld staffers got together to chat about the best apps they've been using recently. Here are some that have recently captured our imaginations (and perhaps a spot on our homescreens), whether they're tiny apps from budding developers or the top-grossing apps that everyone is using. Our hope is that, while you might recognize some of these apps, others you might never have encountered. All of them, we think, are worth a look.


Microsoft's productivity drive could kill software as we know it

On Thursday, Satya Nadella charted a new course for Microsoft, focused on interconnectivity and productivity--one where, conceivably, the company's standard-setting Office applications and other products and services could slowly blur into different modes of working with the same data.


All about DDR4, the next-gen memory coming soon for PCs and mobile devices

New CPU and GPU architectures roil the market pretty much every year--sometimes more than once a year. Yet in spite of the impact that system memory can have on a PC's performance, the industry has relied on the same basic memory architecture for what seems like an eternity--in tech time, at least.


Apple's HomeKit hub may already be in your house

At Apple's recent Worldwide Developers Conference, the company announced--among a great many other things--HomeKit, a suite of tools for controlling such devices in your home as thermostats, furnaces and air conditioners, smart appliances, lights, cameras, garage-door openers, and security systems. Apple will provide a platform that these devices will be asked to conform to. Do so, and you can control them all from your iOS device.

Editors Pick


Apple doesn't need its own gadgets to dominate the smart home

If you believe the weekend rumors, Apple will announce a connected-home platform next week at WWDC. But before you get too excited about an iThermostat and an iFridge and an iCamera watching you sleep, consider this: If Apple does get into the home-automation market, that doesn't necessarily mean it'll make smart-home gadgets of its own.


10 things we want to see in Microsoft's Surface Mini

If Microsoft indeed intends to release a shrunk-down Surface Mini this month, as an invite for a "small" Surface event suggests, merely downsizing the tablet's design to fit an 8-inch frame ain't going to cut it. Sure, the Surface Pro 2 and Surface 2 are beautiful pieces of kit, but they're made for big-screen productivity--the Surface Pro is essentially an Ultrabook without a keyboard. That experience won't translate well to a smaller form factor, better suited for content consumption than content creation.


With this phone, I thee wed: How the Nokia-Microsoft union changes everything

There's no getting cold feet now. On Friday, Microsoft's acquisition of Nokia's device business will be official, after months of delays and regulatory hurdles. The remnants of Nokia will get a whopping $7.2 billion. In return, Microsoft will get 32,000 new employees, a legion of Lumias, and oh yeah, those funky Android-based Nokia X phones.

Latest Product Reviews


MediaBeam: This ultra-cheap streaming stick isn't worth the money

Just what the world needs: another HDMI dongle to compete with Google's Chromecast and Roku's Streaming Stick. Like those popular devices, Ematic's MediaBeam plugs directly into one of your HDTV's HDMI ports in order to stream content.


Samsung Gear Live: It's the world's best smartwatch, but probably not for long

The Gear Live is the best smartwatch I've ever used--but that's not a remarkable achievement considering all the crappy-to-middling efforts we've seen from Samsung, Sony and Qualcomm. If I were being generous, I'd say Samsung finally landed on a simple, wrist-friendly interface that does away with messy nested menus and convoluted features like voice calling.


OnePlus One: You're in control with this ultra-affordable phone

There's a utopian idea behind the OnePlus One: Offer a phone powered by the latest hardware and featuring a wealth of carrier options without any carrier restrictions. If that doesn't grab you, the price tag might--it's $300 for an off-contract 16GB model, about half of what you'd pay for phones boasting similar specs. But does the phone deliver a premium experience?


App Factory 1.2: Turn your script into a stand-alone app

Editor's note: The following review is part of Macworld's GemFest 2014. Every day (except weekends) from July until September, the Macworld staff will use the Mac Gems blog to briefly cover a standout free, low-cost, or great-value program. You can view a list of this year's apps, updated daily, on our handy GemFest chart, and you can visit the Mac Gems homepage for past Mac Gems reviews.